I stepped onto the Red Line train at Metro Center and scanned up and down the car for an empty seat. There was only one, directly behind a teenage couple engaged in a full on make-out session. Reluctantly, I took the seat.
I was listening to the latest edition of the
"This American Life" podcast. The topic was "breakups" or rather, dealing with breakups. I found this incredibly ironic because it took me only approximately 10 seconds of sitting behind "kissing couple" to know that their relationship would at some point result in a tragic breakup... the kind suitable for retelling on the very episode of "This American Life" that I was listening to as they passionaltly embraced right in front of me.
Not only could I tell that the relationship would end poorly, but I could even tell who would be the one left with the broken heart.
They were both attractive people. The girl had long, dark, flowing hair, and big puffy lips... the kind of girl I'm prone to falling in love with on just about any other day on the metro.
The guy had long hair, pulled back into a pony tail, and soft, pretty facial features that were slightly offset by unkempt facial hair that left him with a rebellious twist. I wrote in my journal that he looked like Che Guevara but if Che had been an Italian soccer player obsessed with having "good hair".
"Che" was sprawled across his ladies lap and in between kisses he closed his eyes and tried to drift off to sleep. "Penelope" (that's what I've decided to call his romantic counterpart) starred at him longingly when he closed his eyes and ran her fingers tips up and down his cheek brushing against his ear.
She was trying to let him sleep but every few seconds she couldn't help herself and would lower her lips to his face and plant soft kisses on his closed eyelids, his nose, his mouth.
"Che" would open his eyes, they would kiss passionately for a few seconds, and then he would close his eyes again and the process would repeat...
Finally, she left him alone long enough for him to drift off to sleep... and as if on cue, his phone rang... he stirred awake and answered the phone. I couldn't hear what he was saying, but the entire time he was trying to talk "Penelope" was back to her old tricks, kissing his ear, his cheek, his forehead, etc.
There was a trace of annoyance on his face. It went unspoken but it was there to be seen, and really, who could blame him? How could he
not be annoyed by constant facial touching?
"He's probably too nice a guy to protest," I wrote... "But eventually, he will..."
It was plain to see that she
needed him more than he
needed her. And that's a recipe for disaster.
In 3 months he'll dump her for being so smothering, but he won't tell her why. Maybe
he won't even know why... But he'll move on and she won't... She'll stalk him on MySpace, pick a fight with his new girlfriend at the mall, and finally key his car in an act of desperation... you know, as a final expression of "her love".
We can only hope the whole saga ends up on Judge Judy someday.
In honor of the kissing couple seated next to me on the train, and in honor of the "This American Life" segment on breakups, I figured it would be a good time for us all to tell breakup stories... I'll start with one of my own, and then you guys can share your own in the comments section.
Mine will be a little unconventional... Usually when you think of a breakup story you think of one where
your heart was broken, but I'm going to tell one about breaking someone else's heart.
It starts in High School where I had a girlfriend that was totally, completely, utterly in love with me in the way only a teenage girl can be. I dare say she loved me just as much as "Penelope" loved "Che".
And I loved her too, but not with the kind of love that could honestly rival hers. In fact, her passion was
so strong that I could never fully believe it. Having the self esteem of a 16 year old boy, it was just incomprehensible that someone could love
me that much
. I wanted to know why...
Part of me felt that she only loved me because she was a teenage girl and she thought she was
supposed to be "in love" with her boyfriend. By my way of thinking, it wasn't even anything special about me, It was just the
idea of me, the boyfriend. I could never fully accept that- indeed- this beautiful girl was really in love with me for me.
So every couple weeks I would do something to test her love... At the time I didn't even realize that I was testing her, but looking back on it now with the eyes of an adult I can see that clearly, that's what I was doing.
I would act distant or cold towards her for days at a time for no apparent reason and give no explanation. I would flirt with other girls. Mention in passing how her friend Eva was really cute in that new dress. I would forget to meet her in between classes... All the typical teenage mind games.
All of this was in an effort to see how she reacted. As long as my actions could hurt her, then I could see her emotions were real... If I could make her cry, then that must mean she loved me. Right?
It was all very juvenile behavior, but then again, I
was a juvenile!
We ended up breaking up several times but we always got back together. Then finally, after about a year together I started to get bored... I had eyes for a Puerto Rican beauty in my Geometry class and so I started looking for a way out... But because I wasn't man enough to just breakup with her, I needed to somehow make it
her fault.
Then one day I got my chance when Moe Greene saw some guy on the football team pass my girlfriend a note... that was all I needed. I confronted her about it the next day and she told me that indeed, the football player had given her a note asking her out on a date, but that she had turned him down.
She had even kept the note, as well as her rejection reply just in case I didn't believe her. The only reason she hadn't told me about it in the first place was that she thought I might try to pick a fight with this romantic rival... Of course I
knew she was telling the truth, but I pretended not to believe her. I refused to read the notes or even listen to her explanations any further. I dumped her on the spot for her "cold hearted betrayal".
And of course she cried... but the novelty of being able to make her cry for me had finally worn off. It was
really over this time.
Of course I never got the girl from my Geometry class, never even got the courage to tell her how I felt... And after a few months, my ex-girlfriend started dating someone new, though it was not the football player... I remember feeling hurt that she moved on, but at the same time I knew it was her right to do so. We wouldn't speak for another 2 and half years.
We were both taking classes at a local community college when we ran into each other. She was still with the "new guy" but he had enlisted in the Army and was away at boot camp. We shared an awkward lunch and made small talk. And then, without provocation, she brought up the breakup.
"I was telling the truth about that football player you know, if you had only just read the notes...," she told me.
I conceded that I had believed her all along and went on to tell her the real story about what had really happened... About how I had wanted out of the relationship but didn't know how to get out... About my crush on the girl from Geometry... And about how stunned I was when I saw her with "the new guy" a few months after our breakup... I told her everything.
When I finished, she was crying. I reached my hand out to try and comfort her but she slapped it away. She called me a bastard. Told me that I had broken her heart, and that she cried herself to sleep for weeks after I dumped her. In fact, she claimed that she dated "the new guy" for 6 weeks before she would even kiss him because she had still been so in-love with me!
I felt terrible of course... but at the same time I felt powerful. All those juvenile feelings came out again... "It's been 2 and half years and I can still make her cry! She must have
really loved me!"
I spent the rest of the semester trying to woo her back. I vowed that I'd never hurt her again if she just gave me another chance... and I
really meant it. But to her credit, she had learned from her mistake. She would never let me hurt her again she claimed.
But I didn't listen. I tried everything I could to win back her trust... flowers... jewelry... I even woke up at 6 am every Tuesday and Thursday to pick her up from her house and drop her off at school even though my classes didn't start until noon... But nothing could be done.
She had finally moved on and now I was the one left broken hearted. After the semester ended and she no longer needed a ride to that 6 am class we would pass each other on campus and she wouldn't even acknowledge me. Not even a wave, head nod, or even eye contact. I ended up dropping my classes and taking a job working the night shift at a gas station.
Every night at the gas station I would listen to "I Wonder" by Chris Issac over and over again on my discman... The song seemed to perfectly capture how I felt... I had found true love, accidentally thrown it away, and now it was lost forever. I'm pretty sure my obsession with that song prolonged my misery by at least 3 months, but of course, if a song by Chris Issac can have such a profound effect on you then you probably deserve to be depressed anyway.
I didn't know it then but becoming obsessed with a single song after a heartbreak would become a pattern for me. Here's a list of a couple others that I would later on become obsessed with:
"Take Another Little Piece of My Heart" - Janis Joplin
"Dammit" - Blink 182
"A Long December" - The Counting Crows
"Ensename a Olvidar" - Aventura
"You Don't Have to Say You Love Me" - Dusty Springfield
So there it is... My breakup story. Now lets hear yours. It can be about you being dumped, about you dumping someone else, how you got over being dumped,
anything, as long as it involves someone being dumped. It can be from last week or third grade... You can be brief or you can ramble on about every detail... FITS is here for you. Get it out, I'm in a mood to read about other people's misery... bonus points if you can include any good breakup songs.